MedTech Solutions is considering expanding their manufacturing capabilities to support a new AI-powered diagnostic device. The leadership team must decide whether to build a new production facility, upgrade the existing facility, or outsource production. Each option carries different costs, probabilities of market demand scenarios, and potential payoffs.
Option 1: Build New Facility
- Cost: $1.2 million
- Strong Demand (60%): Gain $2.5 million
- Weak Demand (40%): Gain $1.0 million
Option 2: Upgrade Existing Facility
- Cost: $600,000
- Strong Demand (50%): Gain $1.6 million
- Weak Demand (50%): Gain $900,000
Option 3: Outsource Production
- Cost: $300,000
- Strong Demand (40%): Gain $1.2 million
- Weak Demand (60%): Gain $500,000
Part 1: Excel Decision Tree Model
Build a decision tree in Excel that includes:
- All three options
- Chance nodes (with demand probabilities)
- Associated payoffs (subtracting the cost from revenue)
- Expected Monetary Value (EMV) for each branch
Highlight your final recommendation based on the EMV calculation.
Part 2: Sensitivity Analysis
Perform a sensitivity analysis by:
- Adjusting the probability of strong demand by 10% for each decision path
- Adjusting the strong demand payoff by 20% for at least one option
- Recalculating EMVs and determining if the optimal decision changes
In Excel, clearly show the impact of these changes in a side-by-side comparison.
Part 3: Video Presentation (1015 Minutes)
Create a narrated video walkthrough in which you:
Explain your decision tree step-by-step:
- Why each node, branch, and payoff was set up the way it was
- How you calculated EMV
Demonstrate your sensitivity analysis:
- Show how the EMVs and decisions change when inputs are modified
- Explain which factors had the biggest impact on the final decision
Discuss stakeholder engagement:
- Explain how your analysis and modeling can be used to build stakeholder confidence
- Share strategies for communicating your recommendation persuasively and transparently
- Use visuals (Excel spreadsheet, PowerPoint if needed), and speak clearly as though presenting to executives or a project team.
Written Summary (400600 Words)
Along with your Excel file and video, submit a brief summary that includes:
- Final decision and rationale
- Key takeaways from the sensitivity analysis
- Stakeholder communication strategy
Submission Checklist:
Excel file with decision tree and sensitivity analysis
1015 minute video presentation
Written summary ( Word)
Useful Videos for Project:
Requirements:
- There is no minimum or maximum required number of pages. Your analysis will be considered complete, if it addresses all the components outlined above.
- Use of proper APA formatting and citations. If supporting evidence from outside resources is used those must be properly cited. A minimum of 4 sources (excluding the course textbook) from scholarly articles or business periodicals is required.
- Include your best critical thinking and analysis to arrive at your justification.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.