Writing Reflection ”When Mr. Pirzada Came to Dine”

Instructions for Writing Reflection Assignment:

Topic:

After reading “When Mr. Pirzada Came to Dine” by Jhumpa Lahiri, reflect on the theme of cultural identity and displacement in the story. Write an essay in MLA format that includes a clear thesis statement, two supporting body paragraphs, and textual evidence to support your analysis. Utilize the paragraph structure provided below for each body paragraph. Begin with a thesis statement. Do not write an introduction or conclusion, just a thesis statement and two body paragraphs following the format below:

Writing Prompt:

Choose one of the following questions to answer using the provided paragraph structure:

1. How does the story depict the complexities of cultural identity through the character of Lilia?

OR

2. In what ways does Mr. Pirzada’s experience of displacement reflect the broader theme of longing and separation in the narrative?

I. Start with your thesis statement. Underline it.

II. Body Paragraph Structure:

Paragraph 1:

Label each part of your paragraph before your sentence begins.

a) Topic Sentence: Introduce your argument or analysis in response to the selected question.

b) Elaboration: Provide context and explanation for your argument, considering key details from the story.

c) Example from the story: Select a specific passage or event from the text that supports your argument.

d) Direct Quote: Insert a direct quote from the text to reinforce your point.

e) Explain the Quote and Tie it to the Thesis: Analyze the significance of the quote in relation to your argument and the broader theme of cultural identity or displacement.

Transition to the next paragraph.

Repeat the same format for the second paragraph.

Paragraph 2:

a) Topic Sentence: Introduce a new aspect of your argument or analysis, building on the previous paragraph.

b) Elaboration: Expand upon your argument with additional context or evidence from the story.

c) Example from the story: Choose another relevant passage or event to support your argument.

d) Direct Quote: Incorporate a direct quote from the text to strengthen your analysis.

e) Explain the Quote and Tie it to the Thesis: Interpret the quote in relation to your argument and its connection to the central themes of the story.