How the change in enthelpy and entropy not the only criteria…

1. The Conflict of Drivers

In nature, there are two primary tendencies:

  • Enthalpy ($Delta H$): Systems generally want to move toward a lower energy state (exothermic, $-Delta H$).
  • Entropy ($Delta S$): Systems generally move toward a state of higher disorder (positive, $+Delta S$).

The problem is that many processes are endothermic (absorbing heat) but still happen spontaneously (like ice melting at room temperature). Conversely, some processes decrease disorder (like water freezing) but occur spontaneously at low temperatures. If you only looked at one criterion, you would get the prediction wrong half the time.

2. The Role of Temperature

Temperature acts as a “weighting factor” for entropy.

  • At low temperatures, the enthalpy change ($Delta H$) usually dominates the direction of the reaction.
  • At high temperatures, the entropy change ($Delta S$) becomes the more significant factor.

Because the surroundings and the system are constantly exchanging energy, a process that seems “disfavorable” for the system might be “favorable” for the universe once you factor in the heat released to the environment.


3. The Deciding Factor: Gibbs Free Energy

To solve this tug-of-war, scientists use Gibbs Free Energy ($G$). It combines enthalpy, entropy, and temperature into a single value that represents the “total” energy available to do work.

The relationship is defined by the equation:

$$Delta G = Delta H – TDelta S$$

The True Criterion for Spontaneity:

A process is only spontaneous if the Total Free Energy decreases ($Delta G < 0$).

H S Spontaneity (G<0)
Negative (Exothermic) Positive (More Disorder) Always Spontaneous
Positive (Endothermic) Negative (Less Disorder) Never Spontaneous
Negative (Exothermic) Negative (Less Disorder) Spontaneous only at Low Temps
Positive (Endothermic) Positive (More Disorder) Spontaneous only at High Temps

4. The “Universe” Perspective

The Second Law of Thermodynamics states that for a process to be spontaneous, the entropy of the universe must increase:

$$Delta S_{univ} = Delta S_{sys} + Delta S_{surr} > 0$$

Enthalpy matters because it dictates $Delta S_{surr}$ (heat released to the surroundings increases their entropy). Therefore, Gibbs Free Energy is essentially a clever way of measuring the entropy change of the entire universe using only the properties of your system.

WRITE MY PAPER

Comments

Leave a Reply