Reply to a discussion post (peer response)

Prompt: Add a new example from a different video and show how it supports or complicates their argument.

Peer Post:

In Ethnicity and Identity, ethnicity and nationality are not the same thing. Ethnicity is more about shared culture, traditions, ancestry, and language, while nationality is about belonging to a country or nation. In the Peruvian Festival scene from Ethnicity and Identity, there is a blended identity because people are showing cultural symbols like traditional dress, music, and food, but they are also connected to a national identity at the same time. That scene shows that a person can carry both ethnic and national identity together instead of choosing only one.

One constructionist concept from Chapter 4 is boundary. Chapter 4 explains that identity construction involves drawing a line between us and them, using markers like language, cultural practice, or behavior. You can see this clearly in Preserving the Ways – Culture and Traditions. The video focuses on Native Americans trying to keep their traditions alive, and those traditions act like boundary markers because they separate Native identity from the larger mainstream culture. Another concept is meaning. Chapter 4 says identity is not just about drawing boundaries, but also about attaching value and significance to the group. In Preserving the culture of the Co Tu ethnic minority people, the effort to preserve culture shows that traditions, practices, and heritage are not random things. They carry meaning because they tell people who they are and why their identity matters.

Two identity pressures that stand out are in Preserving the Ways and Ethnicity and Identity. In Preserving the Ways, the pressure comes from historical suppression and the struggle to survive while protecting culture. That means outside power has often tried to define Native identity, but insiders keep asserting it through tradition and memory. In Ethnicity and Identity, the pressure is more about assimilation and cultural erosion. People may start losing language, traditions, or symbols as they blend into mainstream society, which makes identity thinner over time. I think a good example of cultural erosion would be Italian Americans in todays society. Over time the Italian culture has been dwindled down and some would even argue the culture is quite different compared to Italian in Italy.

How do festivals, traditions, and cultural practices help a group resist assimilation while still adapting to modern society?

Videos:

WRITE MY PAPER

Comments

Leave a Reply