Writing Question

Assignment Overview

This essay should be a minimum of 600 words, written in MLA format (double-spaced, Times New Roman font, size 12). The focus will be on rhetorical analysis. You will analyze 1.3.4 Guthman, which we discussed in class. Specifically, you will first identify the “what” (i.e., what the argument is) and then address the “how” (i.e., how the article supports the identified argument). You will break down its rhetorical moves, identify its purpose and audience, and make a claim about whether or not the argument is successful. This will get you thinking about how people talk and argue about the issue of food, who makes up the audience(s) invested in this issue, and how the author makes appeals designed to reach their audience.

Skills and Goals

Summary

Rhetorical Analysis

Tasks

  1. Re-read the assigned essay.
  2. In your essay, start by providing a brief summary of the article. What is the point of the author? What is the main argument?
  3. After summarizing, analyze the article in the rest of the paper. In terms of your analysis, focus on the rhetorical strategies that are most interesting or obvious to you, or that you think are most important to the success of the argument. Below are some examples of concepts that you could discuss.

The authors use of emotional appeals

How the author establishes his or her credibility and/or the credibility of the texts container (i.e. the publication, website, etc.)

How the texts logic works. Is the logic dependent upon a definition or fact? Is it dependent on a cause/effect relationship? A comparison and contrast? How does the logical reasoning work? Does the author use data or statistics to support their argument?

Is this genre of writing the most effective for this particular argument/ audience/rhetorical situation? How so?

Themes that are repeated

Again, rather than trying to address everything on the list above, which would be impossible, discuss what you think the texts most important or notable rhetorical features are. Remember that the goal of this assignment is not to show whether or not you agree with the argument being made in the piece you chose. In fact, your reader shouldn’t be able to tell what your opinion is on the topic. Instead, youre being asked to make an argumentusing evidence from the textthat articulates whether the argument in the text was effective in persuading its intended audience.

Tips

  1. Make sure to re-read this assignment prompt throughout the writing process and especially before you turn it in.
  2. Your biggest charge is to answer the HOW question: HOW does this argument work?
  3. As evidence for your answer for, make sure to quote specific languages from the essay.
  4. Do not bring additional research into this essay.

Grading Criteria

Does this essay move past summary and/or opinion and into analysis? In other words, is there evidence from the text that supports the claims being made?

Rubric

Rhetorical Analysis Essay Grading Rubric (1)

Rhetorical Analysis Essay Grading Rubric (1)

Criteria Ratings Pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeAnalysis of Rhetorical Strategies

15 ptsFull MarksThoroughly analyzes rhetorical strategies, focusing on the most significant elements. Provides strong evidence from the text to support the analysis.10 ptsAverageThere are clear attempts at close reading, but they are sometimes not fully developed. At times, the essay shifts away from analysis and leans more toward summary.

5 ptsNo MarksMinimal or lack of analysis of rhetorical strategies with significant omissions or lack of evidence. No meaningful engagement with the text.

15 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeOrganization and Structure

5 ptsFull MarksThe essay is well-organized, with a clear sense of overall structure. Ideas flow logically, and transitions are smooth, making the analysis easy to follow.0 ptsNo MarksThe essay feels disjointed or hard to follow in places. Ideas are presented without logical progression

5 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeIdentification of the main argument

5 ptsFull MarksThe essay accurately identifies the main point of the article before analyzing its rhetorical moves.0 ptsNo MarksThe essay does not identify, or inaccurately identifies, the main point of the article.

5 pts

Total Points: 25

WRITE MY PAPER

Comments

Leave a Reply